Za[Blac]k-mailed into giving

Blackmail is a very profitable venture to get your hands on something which isn’t really yours. As for our community, let’s just say we Pakistanis have got it fine-tuned to an art. Not just blackmail, every kind of deviously schemin’ trick in the book, or even ones that are not in the book; we know them.

Maybe this is one of the reasons why an average Pakistani must think thrice before parting with its money. The sad thing is, whenever we do part with it for the benefit of others, it’s for a lost cause. My target this time; Professional Beggary!

It’s a thriving business in Pakistan and especially in a cosmopolitan city like Karachi, this profession has struck gold. At almost every other traffic signal, you’re surrounded by a horde of ‘in-needs’ employing various techniques to get you to give something in their direction. They use efficiently memorized stories, verses, songs and ballads to move your supposed heart of stone and get you to have pity on them. Then you think what will become of these poor creatures in this mad bad world and thinking of it as saintly behaviour, you give them something. When you do give something, you are showered with praise. When you DON’T, Oh you should hear’em talking!

Let’s talk about the situation specifically in Ramzan. Twenty times a day, different people come at your house and all of them are in dire need of financial aid. Father, mother, son … some one is always dying and naturally, the poor ones must come on the streets and beg for help (sarcasm). After every Namaz in the Masjid, someone would get up and describe his need to the meditating public. A long line of beggars would litter the entrance to the masjid, depicting sorrow and misery in the hope of earning some cash. Come Ramzan, and suddenly it’s a free license to be out on the streets, spread your hands … and start begging!

I give an impression of myself as a cold-hearted toad that was found under a stone, I know … but let me explain why I dislike this practice so much. It’s not rocket science to understand who is faking distress and who is not. People in need generally don’t go around begging publicly for help, day after day, month after month. They don’t appear in a sacred month like mice from their bills, knocking unashamedly at each door, hunting opportunities to earn like businessmen hunt clients. This is where the blackmail comes in. The problem is; we as a nation are so religiously confused about our responsibilities that we might just about believe anyone. The trump card that professional beggars hold is the ease at which our confused ideologies can be bent or changed. The Muslim part of our community becomes so religiously motivated in Ramzan (not a bad thing); we happily start spending money on fake ‘in-needs’, leaving it to God to credit us for our generosity. Zakat is such a burden that we get it off our chests under the smallest of religious blackmailing. We spend in the name of Zakat, Khairaat, Sadqaat … but it is none of it, if you understand the true essence of its purpose! This kind of giving is for a lost cause. We help people that aren’t interested in helping themselves. Beggary is as much a profession for them as accounting/ engineering / medicine is to us. The non-Muslim community is not free from this plague either. They are emotionally blackmailed by questioning their sense of ethics and human empathy.

I am not against Zakat. I am not against social welfare. All I am saying is, there are a precious few resources to cater to a lot of people in our country. Let’s not waste our sympathies and generosity on people who don’t deserve it. All one needs to do is a little scouring to find people who really need help. Hard to believe, but there are people who still find peace in making an honest living, but lack the resources that could help them go on with their lives.

Providing food would only attract more spread-out hands. Showing them how to be in a position to buy their own food will help our community far more. We must adopt ways to TEACH, not to FEED. Tell me, why would someone in real need cringe and walk away when I offer someone a job instead of money when they beg? It’s the most well known secret that a whole Mafia operates this network of beggars and their earnings per day are quite astounding; it is a well established business. It’s infuriating and quite a revelation to see the preferred mode of aid is always cash. Rarely do they appreciate food, and NEVER a job offer! Most of them are shameless people who’d swear upon anything to prove their honesty, expose their infants to the cruel Karachi sun without clothes on just to portray a more miserable picture. What is worse is they subject their innocent children who are too young to even understand what they do, to this cruel way of life. Most of these children become drug addicts at a cringe-inducing young age. It’s time we start doing a little hard work to help those who really deserve it. I say Hard Work cuz who really deserve charity are NOT on the streets. These beggars; their lives would start and end with the same business, and they will keep on polluting the society with dishonesty, deceit and the general lethargic attitude that has currently gripped the nation.

The beggary business only thrives because of gullible minds that are easy to trick, easy to religiously blackmail. A way out may be to increase social welfare work and direct it towards those who are more focused on self-respect rather than self-pity; who want to stand, not carried through life. People who just need someone to put them in a position where self-sustainability can be achieved. These are the people that could contribute to society and our country as well. They are more likely to be productive for our nation; they may go ahead to form true drivers of change … because hell yes, we need them!

And yes, let’s not be Zakat[Black]-mailed into giving!

Advertisements

About Hamza

A freebird at heart, I believe I am past the age where I can describe myself. I mean, haven’t we seen enough rape of the most commonly used adjectives ? Unless I find something different to describe myself, freebird should do it !

Posted on February 20, 2012, in Socio-political Views and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink. 2 Comments.

  1. Thank you for writing on this subject!
    Professional beggary is growing and expanding by the day, in most urban areas in Pakistan.

    You well-encapsulated the whole scenario revolving around this sector of profession/mafia in our country and why they aren’t willing to be taught to fish, rather than being fed for the day with a single one.

    My father has an opinion on this. He says, that all those able people begging in Pakistan, should be listed by the police or another authority of that particular place or mohalla, taken away with them and even locked up, if necessary – considering innumerable are part of this as a profession, and then, the needs of every different house in that area should be recorded (A family residing there needs a driver/cook etc) and then those beggars should be offered for employment to those houses, in consideration of their abilities. They should be trained, if required.

    That way, beggary could be reduced, to some extent, and employement could be generated too.

    A little too far-fetched and idealistic an idea, given the conditions in Pakistan, but I don’t think its a bad one either.

    • Thank you for taking out the time to comment on this post.

      The thing is, all authorities are most probably well aware of the rings operating behind these beggars. I asked once of my law teacher, and when a lawyer can know so much about this, it’s impossible that law-enforcement authorities are not aware of this.

      This is why your father’s idea, ideal and wonderful though it is, is less likely to work. You can’t say with confidence that the authorities are not in on this ! So unless you first implement a system, that is free from kickbacks and deals with rogues, it can’t happen! In an ideal scenario, it would be simply great if the state could take up responsibility of people with no source of income, and provide them that source.

      I do wish though, that a time comes when your father’s noble idea can bear fruition : )

      The only thing I see that we can all do at an individual level is to stop giving them any kind of money. Close this side of the business! Maybe that wouldn’t be too bad a start?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Farafinna

Finding my African self

Carol Anne Grayson (Radical Sister) blog

I studied and write on human rights, War on Terror, socio-political issues.

Ashish Shakya

Writer. Stand-up comic. General idiot for hire.

Shyikh Mahdi's Blog

"Lethargic lawyer with itchy feet...."

Michael Jeh

I run lifeskills programs for sporting teams, schools and parent groups

Mere Do Paisay

Provocative Commentary

Writer Meets World

Using words to conquer life.

Safire Dreams

meanderings in the mundane

Just Thinking

Pondering the Word

nisasite's blog

if it makes sense to u..ur not reading it right

HarsH ReaLiTy

A Good Blog is Hard to Find

drnaumanshad

A great WordPress.com site

Sana Farzand

My Parallel Universe

%d bloggers like this: